Update: This example is probably a misunderstanding on my part. But, I’m leaving it up anyway.

Okay, I admit it. This one is sort of minor. I guess I’m just taking the opportunity to pick on Kevin Smith. Not a big Smith fan… Anyway, below, in the very beginning of issue #4 (vol 2) we see DD talking to Natasha about his recent incarceration (which happened in issue #3) where he was held prisoner in a very spooky white room with even spookier sound effects. Considering what happened to him in that room, it’s a little surprising to see him describe to room by its color.

First of all, would he even know that the room was white? I wouldn’t have found it odd had he referred to it as “bright,” but I don’t really buy that he can sense colors. And, even if he could, something like that would probably be very far down the list of things that would have stood out to him about that room. Wouldn’t it have made more sense for him to have described the room as “the room with hellish synthetic angel shrieks which messed up my head for an hour”?

Daredevil meets Natasha and tells her he's been held in a white room, as seen in Daredevil #4 (vol 2).

But I guess compared to some other goofs we’ve seen in this category, this one wasn’t that bad. So, to smooth things over with you my dear readers, I offer you a second goof from this arc, taken from issue #3.

Just after Foggy’s arrest for murder, Matt storms into his office and asks for a paralegal. The guy below, Reggie apparently, comes to his aid. Or does he? Is this a case of the staff playing mean tricks on the blind guy or just a simple case of Joe Quesada (who supplied the art for this arc) confusing his own left with Matt’s?

Although this Reggie guy must think Matt’s hearing is screwy too, because most people, whether blind or sighted, have no problem determining where someone’s voice is coming from. Whatever happened to Reggie, I wonder. He might still work for Razor Sharpe. Who knows?

A paralegal, Reggie, tells Matt he's on his left, when he's actually on his right. As seen in Daredevil #4 (vol 2).
Christine Hanefalk

Christine Hanefalk

Based in Stockholm, Sweden, Christine is a die-hard Daredevil fan who launched The Other Murdock Papers in 2007 to share her passion for Matt Murdock and his friends with other fans.

5 comments

  1. I just read Guardian Devil for the first time and I noticed Reggie not being in any way helpful. The white room slipped by me though.

    There were quite a few errors throughout the book, though these were mostly lettering errors.

    I still enjoyed the story though.

  2. Damn how he’s ugly in the fourth panel.

  3. I came back to Daredevil through reading Guardian Devil as a trade after years and years away, so I’m quite keen on it. I know that you don’t dig the emphasis on Matt’s Catholicism that Smith highlighted but I did think it was quite well done.

    I’m with you on the whole white thing – it’s perhaps just conceivable that he could have guessed the colour – white would be much easier, due to its lightness, than, say, purple or green – and may have been recalling what it was like to close his eyes on a bright day when he was able to see. It’s still a bit of a faux pas, though.

  4. Matt's reference to a 'white room' was not a reference to its color, but a common sensory deprivation torture method. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_torture

    As an oldtime spy, Natasha would understand the shorthand.

  5. Ah, thanks for clearing that up! Although in Matt's case, sensory deprivation sounds like bliss (well, for a minute or two anyway). I'll update the post with a reference to your comment shortly. 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.